You know the voice. It shows up right before you send the email, walk into the room or put your hand up to say something or for an opportunity. You wait. Then you Double-check. Land then you let someone more qualified go first.

Most leaders I work with call it their inner critic, and they’ve spent years trying to make it be quiet. I understand the impulse. I just don’t think silence is the right goal, and neither does the research.

This voice tends to get loudest not when someone’s coasting, but right as they step into more visibility than they’ve had before. A new role, a bigger team, a seat at the partners’ table. It’s most active exactly where the stakes of being seen as capable feel highest.

Distance, not deletion

University of Michigan psychologist Ethan Kross has spent his career studying what he calls “chatter”, the running commentary in our heads. In his book Chatter, he doesn’t treat the critical voice as something to eliminate. One of his lab’s clearest findings is a small shift with a big effect: when people talk to themselves using “you” or their own name instead of “I” in a stressful moment, they feel less distressed and think more clearly.

“Why did you do that?” instead of “Why did I do that?”

That tiny bit of distance is the point. You don’t need the critic gone. You need enough space to hear it without being run by it.

Kristin Neff’s research at the University of Texas at Austin adds another layer. People who treat themselves with the kindness they’d offer a friend show better resilience, less anxiety and (here’s the bit high achievers don’t expect) more motivation to improve, not less. Self-compassion isn’t the opposite of high standards. It’s what lets you keep pursuing them without burning out.

This one surprises a lot of the leaders I coach. Many were raised on the belief that the critic is what’s driven their success, and that easing off means going soft. The research doesn’t back that up. Louder isn’t the same as more effective.

And here’s a number worth sitting with. Organisational psychologist Tasha Eurich, writing in Harvard Business Review, reported that while about 95 per cent of people believe they’re self-aware, only around 10 to 15 per cent actually are when tested. I had to read that twice. You can’t manage a voice you haven’t accurately identified. That’s the foundation of emotional intelligence: noticing, in real time, whether it’s the critic talking or something steadier.

That something steadier is what I call the advocate. Not a hype voice. A quieter one that remembers the actual evidence of what you’re capable of.

Try this: the Name Swap

Next time the critic takes over, silently talk to yourself using your name or “you”, not “I”.

  • Not “I’m not ready for this,” but “You’ve handled harder rooms than this.”
  • Not “I always mess this up,” but “You’ve been here before, and you got through it.”

Do it once, before the moment you’re dreading, and notice which voice answers back.

Here’s how that can look. A leader heading into a negotiation she’s been dreading all week caught the familiar thought: I’m going to fumble this. She swapped it. You’ve walked out of harder rooms than this with the outcome you wanted. Not a slogan. A specific, true memory she could point to. The swap didn’t erase her nerves. It just meant they weren’t the only voice she could hear.

To be clear, this is in no way positive thinking. Kross’s research suggests the shift works because of the distance the language creates, not because the words are more upbeat. You could name a hard truth the same way: You’re not ready for this yet, and that’s fine, you still have time.

Distance is the mechanism. The positivity is optional.

Being present isn’t about silencing your mind. It’s noticing which voice has the wheel right now, and knowing that you’re the one that gets to choose. It’s some of the most practical work I do in leadership coaching, and you can start it today.

Working with your internal dialogue instead of fighting it is boundary work at its core, the same internal boundaries covered in depth in the Leadership Boundaries Playbook.

Get the Leadership Boundaries Playbook here: Leadership Boundaries Playbook